The Lonely Flowers of the Health Care System:POV assignment – Donnay Jacobs

The Lonely Flowers of the Health Care System

The flower standing alone symbolizes the abandonment people feel when they go to hospital. I chose this picture because many times we forget that ending up in hospital can be physically draining, perhaps due to surgery…but also emotionally draining on the patient who has to go through the hospitalisation process on their own. Patients in the health system feel alone when they are not being supported by their loved ones. It causes them to become discouraged and depressed and this negatively affects their recovery. These are usually the types of patients whom refuse any sort of treatment because they feel as if no one cares for them so why take horrible tasting medications and why endure the pains of needles? They do not see the bigger picture of the health system supporting their health, instead they see how much emotional support they lack. Lack of emotional support leads to depression. Services which these people can access are support groups and also psychologists who are able to offer the necessary support and mental treatment. They can also contact the South African Depression and Anxiety Group. Depressed people who require physiotherapy usually experience it as supportive and this is aside from the fact that it physically helps people feel better. When you are physically healthy, you become mentally healthy. Patients usually feel at ease with their physiotherapist, this causes them to open up about their emotions. Although physios are not counsellors, they do offer understanding ears and can offer advice as well as referrals. Physios can help patients who are experiencing any pain, muscle related problems and the list goes on. When there is no more pain, it automatically results in a boost in their mood and thus relieving depression.

Academic Literature

Research on loneliness has been hampered by its strong association with depression, they frequently co-occur and share common origins (Weeks, Michela, Peplau, & Bragg, 1980). In psychiatry, a patient refusing treatment is generally considered to be evidence of an impaired capacity to make decisions about lifesaving treatment. These are usually patients whom are depressed, it is seen as a reasonable response to a medical illness which can be due to the link with feeling alone (Sullivan & Youngner, 1994). Loneliness can be a problem for elderly people who are hospitalized, children move away and spouses and friends are too frail to visit them. Loneliness is a medical issue, and according to studies there is a link between feeling alone and poor health as well as early death. Hospitals are thus designing studies to find out if volunteer companions improve medical outcomes or improves the patients’ hospital experience (Jaffe, 2016). Reduction of muscular-tonic syndrome and especially of pain syndrome through the developed treatment leads to a significant improvement in the emotional state of patients, this is proof that there is improvement that occurs with physiotherapy (Chukhraev, Vladimirov, Zukow, Chukhraiyeva, & Levkovskaya, 2017).

References

Chukhraev, N., Vladimirov, A., Zukow, W., Chukhraiyeva, O., & Levkovskaya, V. (2017). Combined physiotherapy of anxiety and depression disorders in dorsopathy patients. Journal of Physical Education and Sport, 414-417.

Jaffe, I. (2016, November 21). Health Companions Can Ease Isolation For Older People. Retrieved  29 April, 2019, from npr: https://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2016/11/21/500222611/hospital-companions-ease-isolation-for-older-patients

Sullivan, M. D., & Youngner, S. J. (1994). Depression, competence, and the right to refuse lifesaving medical treatment. The American Journal of Psychiatry, 971-978.

Weeks, D. G., Michela, J. L., Peplau, L. A., & Bragg, M. E. (1980). Relation between loneliness and depression: A structural equation analysis. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 1238-1244.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

2 thoughts on “The Lonely Flowers of the Health Care System:POV assignment – Donnay Jacobs

  1. Hi, Donnay!
    I think you’ve written a really good text, that reflects a topic that we need to be aware of as physiotherapists and that often is forgotten in clinical practice. Of course, as physiotherapist we can have a lot of impact on the patients physical abilities, but I think it’s a good idea that you chose to address other aspects that we can have an impact on. I don’t know if you’ve thought about making a topic text for the assignment, but if I can come with a proposal, maybe it can be something like; “The lonely flowers of the health care system”? The part I liked the most is where you wrote about the risk factors of loneliness and compared it to other disorders that often receives more attention, which really pointed out that this is a challenge that we need to address and be aware of when in our daily practice.

    On another note, I think maybe the first paragraph can use a little work. Many of the points you are making are very important and interesting, but I don’t know if this is something you’ve experienced yourself or something that you’ve found in litterature/research. Is it some kind of litterature that says that patients who don’t feel support by their loved ones feel alone? And is there any research supporting that these are the kinds of patients that whom are stubborn, and that everyone feels supported by their physical therapist? As I mentioned earlier, I think your text is great reading. But if you can find a way to support these claims, or make the sources more visible in the text, I think it would be even better. Maybe you also could point out if this is a regular problem in the South African health care system, or is this more of a global problem?

    A lot of our own lectures focus on these kind of issues, and that the social and psychological aspects of the patients life is as important as the physical aspects. But we haven’t approached this kind of problem so far, during our 2 years of study. Therefore, I think it was a wake up call to read this text and I hope that it will be something that I will take with me into clinical practice and be aware of when meeting patients in the future.

Leave a Reply